Market-Driven Rice Farming and Water Use Change in Mbarali District from the Mid-1980s to the 2010s
Corresponding Author(s) : George K. Ambindwile
Journal of Humanities & Social Science (JHSS),
Vol. 10 No. 4 (2021)
Abstract
This paper examines the effects of market-driven rice farming on the use of water in Mbarali District from about the mid-1980s to 2010s. It specifically traces the development of both peasant and state rice farming and their subsequent effects on water use in the district. The study is essentially qualitative, although in some cases it uses quantitative data to validate its arguments. Thus, it adopts political economy and historical ecology theories to understand changes brought by market-driven rice farming; and the ways peasants struggled to accommodate those changes in their agricultural practices. The area of study included six villages, namely Chimala, Mkombwe, Rujewa, Songwe-Imalilo, Ubaruku and Utengule-Usangu, in Mbeya region, Tanzania. Data of the study is drawn from oral interviews in these villages in three phases between 1999 and 2020; and from an examination of earlier studies (secondary data) and archival documents that provided primary data on government policies, ordinances and decisions. The findings show that the expansion of market-driven rice farming in Mbarali from 25,906ha in 1985 to 45,000ha in 2000 and 65,547ha in 2016 was in response to the economic liberalization drive which began in the mid-1980s. This expansion of market-driven rice farming during that period symbolized the response of the peasants to the new conditions created by the liberalization of the economy. Also, the expansion produced important changes such as prolonged use of water for irrigation, the general calendar change in the water use, etc., which affected the use of water, causing the drying up of some rivers, evolution of intense struggles over water, downstream water scarcity, etc.
Keywords
Download Citation
Endnote/Zotero/Mendeley (RIS)BibTeX
- Bryceson, D.F. 1993. Liberalizing Tanzania’s Food Trade: The Public and Private Faces of Urban Marketing Policy. 1939–88. James Currey. Charnley, S. 1994. Cattle, Commons, and Culture: The Political Ecology of Environmental Change on a Tanzanian Rangeland. PhD thesis, Stanford University. Danida/World Bank. 1995. Water Resources Management in the Great Ruaha Basin: A Study of DemandDriven Management of Land and Water Resources With Local Level Participation. Rufiji Basin Water Office, Ministry of Water, Energy and Minerals. Haapanen, T. 2011. Rural Food System Change in Tanzania During the Post-Ujamaa Era: A Case Study from Western Bagamoyo District. (PhD Thesis). University of Turk. International Bank for Reconstruction and Development (IBRD). 1983. The Economic Development of Tanzania. Johns Hopkins University Press. International Monetary Fund (IMF). 1995. Statement By the IMF Staff Representative. Tanzania Consultative Group. Kashaigili, J. J., M. P. Mccartney, H. F. Mahoo, B. A. Lankford, B. P. Mbilinyi, K. D. Yawson & S. D. Tumbo. 2006. Use of a Hydrological Model for Environmental Management of the Usangu Wetlands, Tanzania. IWMI Research Reports H039649, International Water Management Institute. Kikula, I. S., S. Charnley & P. Yanda. 1996. Ecological Changes in the Usangu Plains and Their Implication son the Down Stream Flow of the Great Ruaha River in Tanzania. Research Report No. 99. University of Dar es Salaam. Lankford, B. A., S Tumbo & K. Rajabu. 2009. Water Competition, Variability and River Basin Governance: A Critical Analysis of the Great Ruaha River, Tanzania. in F. Molle and P. Wester, (Eds). River Basin Trajectories: Societies, Environments and Development (Vol. 8. CAB International), pp 171–295. Lankford, B. A. & T. Franks. 2010. The Sustainable Coexistence of Wetlands and Rice Irrigation: A Case Study from Tanzania. Journal of Environment and Development, 9(2): 119–137. htpp: //jed. sagepub.com/content/9/2/119. Mbarali District. 1997. Annual District Agricultural Report 1996/97. Government Printers. —. 2011. Mbarali District Report on Agriculture. 2001–2010. Government Printers. Mbeya Rural District. 1993. Annual District Agricultural Report. 1992/93. Government Printers. —. 1995. Annual District Agricultural Report 1994/95. Government Printers. Ministry of Agriculture and Cooperative/ Marketing Development Bureau (MAC/MDB). 1995. 1993/94 Industry Review of Maize, Rice and Wheat. Ministry of Agriculture and Cooperatives. Mccartney, M. P., B. A. Lankford & H. F. Mahoo. 2007. Agricultural Water Management in a Water Stressed Catchment: Lessons from the RIPARWIN Project. International Water Management Institute. 52p. Research Report 116. Munishi, E. N. 1999. Future Plans for Expansion of Agricultural Activities in the Usangu Plains. Paper Presented at the Workshop on Environmental Conservation of the Mtera Ecosystem, Iringa. Mutayoba, E, J. J. Kashaigili, F. C. Kahimba, W. Mbungu & N. A. Chilagane. 2018. Assessing the Impacts of Land Use and Land Cover Changes on Hydrology of the Mbarali River Sub-Catchment: The Case of Upper Great Ruaha Sub-Basin, Tanzania. Engineering, 10(9): 616–635. http: //www. scirp.org/journal/eng. Mbeya Zonal Archives (MZA) AGR 1/1 Regional Agricultural Officer. 1964–1974. MZA D.30/99/Vol. II, Kimani Irrigation Project. 1994–1998. MZA Kimani Irrigation Scheme. 1989. Mbeya: D.30/99/Vol. II Kimani Irrigation Project. MZA MDC/A 30/36, Agriculture: Kapunga Rice Farm; NAFCO’s General Manager Applying for Land to Kapunga Village. MZA RDD.13/135, Water Development Irrigation Project. 1975–1990. Ponte, S. 1998. Fast Crops, Fast Crop: Market Liberalization and Rural Livelihoods in Songea and Morogoro Districts, Tanzania. Canadian Journal of African Studies, 32(2): 316–346. https: //www.jstor.org/stable/486152. Ponte, S. 2000. From Social Negotiation to Contract: Shifting Strategies of Farm Labour Recruitment in Tanzania Under Market Liberalization. World Development, 28(6): 1017–1034. 10.1016/S0305– 750X(00)00012–7. Ponte, S. 2002. Farmers and Markets in Tanzania. James Currey. Skarstein, R. 2005. Economic Liberalization and Smallholder Productivity in Tanzania: from Promised Success to Real Failure. 1985–1998. Agrarian Change, 5(3): 334–362. https: //doi.org/10.1111/j.1471–0366.2005.00104.x. Sustainable Management of the Usangu Wetland and its Catchment (SMUWC). 2001. Sustainable Management of the Usangu Wetland and Its Catchment. A Report Submitted to IFAD and Government of Tanzania. Sokoni, C. H. 2008. Commercialization of Smallholder Production in Tanzania: Implications for Sustainable Resource Management. Geographical Journal, 174(2): 158–161. http: //www. jstor. org/stable/40205213. Malima, K. A. 1990/1/1–4. Towards Economic and Social Action Programmes. Workshop on Economic Development and Adjustment Policies After the First ERP. Dar es Salaam. United Nations Development Programme & Food and Agriculture Organisation (UNDP & FAO). 1998. Development of Usangu Village Irrigation: AG: DP/URT/91/005. Rome. United Republic of Tanzania (URT). 1986. Ministry of Agriculture: The Tanzania National Agricultural Policy. Government Printers. —. 1988. The Tanzania National Agricultural Policy. Government Printers. —. 1989. The URT ERP II (Economic and Social Action Programme): 1989/90–1992/93. Government Printers. —. 1999) the Ministry of Agriculture and Cooperatives: Terminal Report: Development of Usangu Village Irrigation (Phase II) URT 91/005. Government Printers. —. 2003. Tanzania National Census of 2002. Government Printers. Word Bank (WB). 1992. A Vision for Sustained Growth in Tanzania. Tanzania Consultative Group
References
Bryceson, D.F. 1993. Liberalizing Tanzania’s Food Trade: The Public and Private Faces of Urban Marketing Policy. 1939–88. James Currey. Charnley, S. 1994. Cattle, Commons, and Culture: The Political Ecology of Environmental Change on a Tanzanian Rangeland. PhD thesis, Stanford University. Danida/World Bank. 1995. Water Resources Management in the Great Ruaha Basin: A Study of DemandDriven Management of Land and Water Resources With Local Level Participation. Rufiji Basin Water Office, Ministry of Water, Energy and Minerals. Haapanen, T. 2011. Rural Food System Change in Tanzania During the Post-Ujamaa Era: A Case Study from Western Bagamoyo District. (PhD Thesis). University of Turk. International Bank for Reconstruction and Development (IBRD). 1983. The Economic Development of Tanzania. Johns Hopkins University Press. International Monetary Fund (IMF). 1995. Statement By the IMF Staff Representative. Tanzania Consultative Group. Kashaigili, J. J., M. P. Mccartney, H. F. Mahoo, B. A. Lankford, B. P. Mbilinyi, K. D. Yawson & S. D. Tumbo. 2006. Use of a Hydrological Model for Environmental Management of the Usangu Wetlands, Tanzania. IWMI Research Reports H039649, International Water Management Institute. Kikula, I. S., S. Charnley & P. Yanda. 1996. Ecological Changes in the Usangu Plains and Their Implication son the Down Stream Flow of the Great Ruaha River in Tanzania. Research Report No. 99. University of Dar es Salaam. Lankford, B. A., S Tumbo & K. Rajabu. 2009. Water Competition, Variability and River Basin Governance: A Critical Analysis of the Great Ruaha River, Tanzania. in F. Molle and P. Wester, (Eds). River Basin Trajectories: Societies, Environments and Development (Vol. 8. CAB International), pp 171–295. Lankford, B. A. & T. Franks. 2010. The Sustainable Coexistence of Wetlands and Rice Irrigation: A Case Study from Tanzania. Journal of Environment and Development, 9(2): 119–137. htpp: //jed. sagepub.com/content/9/2/119. Mbarali District. 1997. Annual District Agricultural Report 1996/97. Government Printers. —. 2011. Mbarali District Report on Agriculture. 2001–2010. Government Printers. Mbeya Rural District. 1993. Annual District Agricultural Report. 1992/93. Government Printers. —. 1995. Annual District Agricultural Report 1994/95. Government Printers. Ministry of Agriculture and Cooperative/ Marketing Development Bureau (MAC/MDB). 1995. 1993/94 Industry Review of Maize, Rice and Wheat. Ministry of Agriculture and Cooperatives. Mccartney, M. P., B. A. Lankford & H. F. Mahoo. 2007. Agricultural Water Management in a Water Stressed Catchment: Lessons from the RIPARWIN Project. International Water Management Institute. 52p. Research Report 116. Munishi, E. N. 1999. Future Plans for Expansion of Agricultural Activities in the Usangu Plains. Paper Presented at the Workshop on Environmental Conservation of the Mtera Ecosystem, Iringa. Mutayoba, E, J. J. Kashaigili, F. C. Kahimba, W. Mbungu & N. A. Chilagane. 2018. Assessing the Impacts of Land Use and Land Cover Changes on Hydrology of the Mbarali River Sub-Catchment: The Case of Upper Great Ruaha Sub-Basin, Tanzania. Engineering, 10(9): 616–635. http: //www. scirp.org/journal/eng. Mbeya Zonal Archives (MZA) AGR 1/1 Regional Agricultural Officer. 1964–1974. MZA D.30/99/Vol. II, Kimani Irrigation Project. 1994–1998. MZA Kimani Irrigation Scheme. 1989. Mbeya: D.30/99/Vol. II Kimani Irrigation Project. MZA MDC/A 30/36, Agriculture: Kapunga Rice Farm; NAFCO’s General Manager Applying for Land to Kapunga Village. MZA RDD.13/135, Water Development Irrigation Project. 1975–1990. Ponte, S. 1998. Fast Crops, Fast Crop: Market Liberalization and Rural Livelihoods in Songea and Morogoro Districts, Tanzania. Canadian Journal of African Studies, 32(2): 316–346. https: //www.jstor.org/stable/486152. Ponte, S. 2000. From Social Negotiation to Contract: Shifting Strategies of Farm Labour Recruitment in Tanzania Under Market Liberalization. World Development, 28(6): 1017–1034. 10.1016/S0305– 750X(00)00012–7. Ponte, S. 2002. Farmers and Markets in Tanzania. James Currey. Skarstein, R. 2005. Economic Liberalization and Smallholder Productivity in Tanzania: from Promised Success to Real Failure. 1985–1998. Agrarian Change, 5(3): 334–362. https: //doi.org/10.1111/j.1471–0366.2005.00104.x. Sustainable Management of the Usangu Wetland and its Catchment (SMUWC). 2001. Sustainable Management of the Usangu Wetland and Its Catchment. A Report Submitted to IFAD and Government of Tanzania. Sokoni, C. H. 2008. Commercialization of Smallholder Production in Tanzania: Implications for Sustainable Resource Management. Geographical Journal, 174(2): 158–161. http: //www. jstor. org/stable/40205213. Malima, K. A. 1990/1/1–4. Towards Economic and Social Action Programmes. Workshop on Economic Development and Adjustment Policies After the First ERP. Dar es Salaam. United Nations Development Programme & Food and Agriculture Organisation (UNDP & FAO). 1998. Development of Usangu Village Irrigation: AG: DP/URT/91/005. Rome. United Republic of Tanzania (URT). 1986. Ministry of Agriculture: The Tanzania National Agricultural Policy. Government Printers. —. 1988. The Tanzania National Agricultural Policy. Government Printers. —. 1989. The URT ERP II (Economic and Social Action Programme): 1989/90–1992/93. Government Printers. —. 1999) the Ministry of Agriculture and Cooperatives: Terminal Report: Development of Usangu Village Irrigation (Phase II) URT 91/005. Government Printers. —. 2003. Tanzania National Census of 2002. Government Printers. Word Bank (WB). 1992. A Vision for Sustained Growth in Tanzania. Tanzania Consultative Group